Post by Mohammed Aarif Waghoo on Mar 3, 2015 10:17:51 GMT 5.5
GAIR MUQALLIDOON kay paas NAMAZ may seenay per haath bandhnay ki na koi Saheeh Hadees hay aur na hi KHAIRULQUROON
[ yani Sahaba , Tabayeen , Tabatabayeen ] ka Amal Namaz may Seenay per haath bandhnay ka Moujood hain .
Sirf aur Sirf Jhoot hain
•Al-quran : Alaa Laanatullahi Alal Kazibeen
•Sunoo ALLAH ki Laanat hay Jhotoon per
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 01
Seenay per haath bandhnay ki riwayaat Bukhari o Muslim may bakasrat hain
[ Fatawa’a Sanaiyya’h page num 443 jild num 1 ]
••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 02
Seenay per haath bandhnay ki riwaayat saheeh hay
[ Bulug ul Maraam ]
[ Fatawa’a Sanaiyya’h page num 593 jild num 5 ]
••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 03
Seenay per haath bandhnay ki riwaayat saheeh ibne khuzaima’h may hay aur ibne khuzaima’h nay is saheeh batlaya hay
[ Fatawa’a Sanaiyya’h page num 457 jild num 1 ]
[ Naiz = Dalayeel e Muhammadi page num 110 Hissa’h 2 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 04
Imam Muhammad Rehmahullah nay Qabeesa’h bin Hulb say is nay apnay Baap say riwaayat ki hay k Nabi Sallallahu Alahi Wasallam Namaz may seenay per haath bandha kartay thay
Ye Hadees Husn hay . Saheeh Bukhari may bhi 1 aesi hi Hadees aati hay . Wallahu Aalam
[ Fatawa’a Sanaiyya’h page 457 jild num 1 ]
••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 05
Abu Dawood may Tauos say Marfuaen aaya hay Seenay per haath bandhna
[ Mukammal Namaz Moulana Abdul Wahab page 449 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 06
Seenay per haath bandhnay ki hadees bilittefaaq Aaiymma’h Muhaddiseen saheeh hain
[ Sharah Wiqaaya’h page 93 ]
[ Haqeqatul Fiqa’h page 250 az Yousuf jay puri ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 07
Naaf kay nechay haath bandhnay ki hadees nahi hay wo Qoul e Ali hay
[ Sharah Wiqaya’h page 93 ]
[ Haqeqat ul Fiqa’h page 250 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 08
Hazrat Mirza Mazhar Jaan Janaao Mujadidi Hanfi Seena’h per haath bandhnay ki hadees ko basabub Qawi honay kay Tarjeeh detay thay aur seenay per haath bandhtay thay
[ Muqadma’h Hidaya’h page 111 jild num 1 ]
[ Haqeqat ul Fiqa’h page 251 jild num 1 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 09
Naaf kay nechay haath bandhnay ki riwayaat bilittefaaq Aaiymma’h Muhaddiseen zaeef hain
[ Hidaya’h page num 1 page num 350 ]
[ Haqeqat ul Fiqa’h page 250 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 10
Qareeban
[ Ikhtelaaf e Ummat ka Almiya’h page num 96 ]
per yahi jhoot hay
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 11
Khalid Girjaakhi
[ Salatun Nabi page num 157 ]
per yahi jhoot manqool hay
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 12
Khulfa’a bani Abbas may say Khalifa’h Haroon ka Namaz may izaar bund khulgaya . Seenay say haath nechay karkay izaar bund sunbhaal liya Muqtadiyoon nay herani say is Fael ko dekha Qazi Abu Yousuf nay Fatwa’a diya k Naaf kay nechay haath bandhna hi saheeh hay
[ Hidaya’h Bab ul Salaat Ikhtelaaf e Ummat ka Almiya’h page num 78 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 13
Ibne Masood ka Qoul Zair e Naaf ka bilkul zaeef hay
[ May nay Rahe Hidaayat kesay paayi page 18 Abu Nouman Basheer Ahmed ]
Halaankay Aap say koi Qoul Manqool nahi
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 14
[ Qurrat ul Aain ] may Noor Husain Girjaakhi nay hadees Wayil bin Hijr naqel karkay 11 kutub kay hawalay diye hay
•JAWAAB•
Halaankay in may say 1 may bhi seenay per haath bandhna sabit nahi hay [ page num 19 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 15
Muslim ki sanad Ibne khuzema’h kay matan kay sath milaadi . Mulahiza’h ho
[ Fatawa’a Sanaiyya’h page num 444 jild num 1 ]
•JAWAAB•
Asal sanad
[ Ibne Khuzema’h page num 243 jild num 1 ] per mulahiza’h
Muslim ki sanad
[ Muslim page num 172 jild num 1 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 16
Hazrat Hulb ki riwaayat may HAAZIHI ko YADAHU banadiya
[ Deen ul Haq Muhammad Dawood Arshad page 217 ]
“Wayasnaau Haazihi Alaa Sadrihi” Asal Lafz is tarah hay
[ Musnad e Ahmed page num 622 jild num 5 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 17
May nay Nabi Akram Sallallahu Alahi Wasallam ko dekha Seenay per haath rakhtay thay
Allama’h Tirmizi Nemvi Hanfi nay iski sanad ko Husm kaha hay
[ Deen ul Haq page num 218 ]
•JAWAAB•
Imam Tirmizi nay seenay per Haath bandhnay ki Riwaayat naqal hi nahi ki Allama’h Nemvi nay naqal karkay seena’h ka Lafz GER MEHFOOZ kaha hay
[ Aasar ul Sunan page num 86 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 18
3 cheezain Nubtwwat ki Aadaat say hain ye riwaayat Hazrat Ali Razi Allahu Aunhu say hergiz nahi
[ Deen ul Haq page num 222 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 19
Phir seenay per haath baandh ker Dua’a pardhay
[ Tirmizi page num 119 jild num 1 ]
[ Salat ul Mustafa Muhammad Ali Jaanbaaz Sheikh ul Hadees page 274 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 20
Wayil bin Hijr ki Ibne Khuzema’h wali riwaayat ki Ibne Hijr nay Tasveeb farmayi hay
[ Fatah ul Baari : 12 Masayeel az Qalam : Kaleem Abdul Rehman Khaleeq page num 53 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 21
Hadees ALI ki waza’ulaidi alal aidi :Alkh ye riwaayat Abu Dawood kay nukhsay Ibne Aerabi kay ilawah diger nasukh may sabit nahi
[ Kitab o Sunnat kay mutabiq Namaz Tarjuma’h ma’a izafa Doctor Khalid Zafrullah page 59 ]
•JAWAAB•
Ibne Dasa’h kay nuskhay’h may hay
[ Adla’h Kamila’h Sheikh ul Hind ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 22
Ta’ajjub hay Moulana Habib ur Rehman Azami nay bhi Hasb e Aadat Mehaz Maslaki Hamiyat may is say ziyada ko shamil MATAN kiya [ Taht ul Sarah ] jesa k Almusannif Matbua’h Maktaba’h Imdadiya’h Makkah may hay
•[ Irshd ul Haq page 229 Tasneef Moulana Sarfaraz Ahmed apni Tasaneef kay Aainay may ]
halaankay
[ Almusannif page num 351 jild num 2 ] per Lafz TAH TUS SARA’H nahi hay
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 23
WANHER ki tafseer Hazrat Ali Razi Allahu Aunhu say mervi hay k is say muraad seenay per haath bandhna hay . Bayain per Dayaan isay Imam Haakim laaye hain aur Husn kaha hay
[ Dalayeel e Muhammadi page num 111 Hissa’h 2 ]
•[ Musannifa’h Allama’h Muhammad Juna Gardhi nay Halaankay HUSN nahi farmaya
[ yani Sahaba , Tabayeen , Tabatabayeen ] ka Amal Namaz may Seenay per haath bandhnay ka Moujood hain .
Sirf aur Sirf Jhoot hain
•Al-quran : Alaa Laanatullahi Alal Kazibeen
•Sunoo ALLAH ki Laanat hay Jhotoon per
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 01
Seenay per haath bandhnay ki riwayaat Bukhari o Muslim may bakasrat hain
[ Fatawa’a Sanaiyya’h page num 443 jild num 1 ]
••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 02
Seenay per haath bandhnay ki riwaayat saheeh hay
[ Bulug ul Maraam ]
[ Fatawa’a Sanaiyya’h page num 593 jild num 5 ]
••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 03
Seenay per haath bandhnay ki riwaayat saheeh ibne khuzaima’h may hay aur ibne khuzaima’h nay is saheeh batlaya hay
[ Fatawa’a Sanaiyya’h page num 457 jild num 1 ]
[ Naiz = Dalayeel e Muhammadi page num 110 Hissa’h 2 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 04
Imam Muhammad Rehmahullah nay Qabeesa’h bin Hulb say is nay apnay Baap say riwaayat ki hay k Nabi Sallallahu Alahi Wasallam Namaz may seenay per haath bandha kartay thay
Ye Hadees Husn hay . Saheeh Bukhari may bhi 1 aesi hi Hadees aati hay . Wallahu Aalam
[ Fatawa’a Sanaiyya’h page 457 jild num 1 ]
••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 05
Abu Dawood may Tauos say Marfuaen aaya hay Seenay per haath bandhna
[ Mukammal Namaz Moulana Abdul Wahab page 449 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 06
Seenay per haath bandhnay ki hadees bilittefaaq Aaiymma’h Muhaddiseen saheeh hain
[ Sharah Wiqaaya’h page 93 ]
[ Haqeqatul Fiqa’h page 250 az Yousuf jay puri ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 07
Naaf kay nechay haath bandhnay ki hadees nahi hay wo Qoul e Ali hay
[ Sharah Wiqaya’h page 93 ]
[ Haqeqat ul Fiqa’h page 250 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 08
Hazrat Mirza Mazhar Jaan Janaao Mujadidi Hanfi Seena’h per haath bandhnay ki hadees ko basabub Qawi honay kay Tarjeeh detay thay aur seenay per haath bandhtay thay
[ Muqadma’h Hidaya’h page 111 jild num 1 ]
[ Haqeqat ul Fiqa’h page 251 jild num 1 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 09
Naaf kay nechay haath bandhnay ki riwayaat bilittefaaq Aaiymma’h Muhaddiseen zaeef hain
[ Hidaya’h page num 1 page num 350 ]
[ Haqeqat ul Fiqa’h page 250 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 10
Qareeban
[ Ikhtelaaf e Ummat ka Almiya’h page num 96 ]
per yahi jhoot hay
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 11
Khalid Girjaakhi
[ Salatun Nabi page num 157 ]
per yahi jhoot manqool hay
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 12
Khulfa’a bani Abbas may say Khalifa’h Haroon ka Namaz may izaar bund khulgaya . Seenay say haath nechay karkay izaar bund sunbhaal liya Muqtadiyoon nay herani say is Fael ko dekha Qazi Abu Yousuf nay Fatwa’a diya k Naaf kay nechay haath bandhna hi saheeh hay
[ Hidaya’h Bab ul Salaat Ikhtelaaf e Ummat ka Almiya’h page num 78 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 13
Ibne Masood ka Qoul Zair e Naaf ka bilkul zaeef hay
[ May nay Rahe Hidaayat kesay paayi page 18 Abu Nouman Basheer Ahmed ]
Halaankay Aap say koi Qoul Manqool nahi
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 14
[ Qurrat ul Aain ] may Noor Husain Girjaakhi nay hadees Wayil bin Hijr naqel karkay 11 kutub kay hawalay diye hay
•JAWAAB•
Halaankay in may say 1 may bhi seenay per haath bandhna sabit nahi hay [ page num 19 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 15
Muslim ki sanad Ibne khuzema’h kay matan kay sath milaadi . Mulahiza’h ho
[ Fatawa’a Sanaiyya’h page num 444 jild num 1 ]
•JAWAAB•
Asal sanad
[ Ibne Khuzema’h page num 243 jild num 1 ] per mulahiza’h
Muslim ki sanad
[ Muslim page num 172 jild num 1 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 16
Hazrat Hulb ki riwaayat may HAAZIHI ko YADAHU banadiya
[ Deen ul Haq Muhammad Dawood Arshad page 217 ]
“Wayasnaau Haazihi Alaa Sadrihi” Asal Lafz is tarah hay
[ Musnad e Ahmed page num 622 jild num 5 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 17
May nay Nabi Akram Sallallahu Alahi Wasallam ko dekha Seenay per haath rakhtay thay
Allama’h Tirmizi Nemvi Hanfi nay iski sanad ko Husm kaha hay
[ Deen ul Haq page num 218 ]
•JAWAAB•
Imam Tirmizi nay seenay per Haath bandhnay ki Riwaayat naqal hi nahi ki Allama’h Nemvi nay naqal karkay seena’h ka Lafz GER MEHFOOZ kaha hay
[ Aasar ul Sunan page num 86 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 18
3 cheezain Nubtwwat ki Aadaat say hain ye riwaayat Hazrat Ali Razi Allahu Aunhu say hergiz nahi
[ Deen ul Haq page num 222 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 19
Phir seenay per haath baandh ker Dua’a pardhay
[ Tirmizi page num 119 jild num 1 ]
[ Salat ul Mustafa Muhammad Ali Jaanbaaz Sheikh ul Hadees page 274 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 20
Wayil bin Hijr ki Ibne Khuzema’h wali riwaayat ki Ibne Hijr nay Tasveeb farmayi hay
[ Fatah ul Baari : 12 Masayeel az Qalam : Kaleem Abdul Rehman Khaleeq page num 53 ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 21
Hadees ALI ki waza’ulaidi alal aidi :Alkh ye riwaayat Abu Dawood kay nukhsay Ibne Aerabi kay ilawah diger nasukh may sabit nahi
[ Kitab o Sunnat kay mutabiq Namaz Tarjuma’h ma’a izafa Doctor Khalid Zafrullah page 59 ]
•JAWAAB•
Ibne Dasa’h kay nuskhay’h may hay
[ Adla’h Kamila’h Sheikh ul Hind ]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 22
Ta’ajjub hay Moulana Habib ur Rehman Azami nay bhi Hasb e Aadat Mehaz Maslaki Hamiyat may is say ziyada ko shamil MATAN kiya [ Taht ul Sarah ] jesa k Almusannif Matbua’h Maktaba’h Imdadiya’h Makkah may hay
•[ Irshd ul Haq page 229 Tasneef Moulana Sarfaraz Ahmed apni Tasaneef kay Aainay may ]
halaankay
[ Almusannif page num 351 jild num 2 ] per Lafz TAH TUS SARA’H nahi hay
•••••••••••••••••••••••••
•JHOOT NUMBER 23
WANHER ki tafseer Hazrat Ali Razi Allahu Aunhu say mervi hay k is say muraad seenay per haath bandhna hay . Bayain per Dayaan isay Imam Haakim laaye hain aur Husn kaha hay
[ Dalayeel e Muhammadi page num 111 Hissa’h 2 ]
•[ Musannifa’h Allama’h Muhammad Juna Gardhi nay Halaankay HUSN nahi farmaya