Post by Mohammed Aarif Waghoo on Dec 25, 2018 11:34:03 GMT 5.5
Some People Object that Saying Ya Muhammad (Ya Rasool Allah) is not proven from Sahaba
We are presenting here the authentic scan from those denier's Imam ibne Taymmiyah
IBN TAMMIYA Ney apni book (good word) mey iss SAHI RIVAYAT sey ISTADLAAL kiya hai, aur iss SAHI rivayat par kisi bhi Tarah ka Koi ETARAZ Waarid nahi kiya hai.
Ibne Taymmiya has done Istidlal (reasoning) from this Sahih narration in his book (Al-Kalim al-Tayib) and neither did he shows any kind of objection on this narration.
IBN TAIMMIYA ki (Ki good) Ki sharah mey Mashoor MOHADDIS HAFIZ BADRUDDIN MEHMOOD AINI HANFI rah 856 Hijri mey bhi iss ISTADLAAL ko barqaraar rakha hai, aur iss rivayat par kisi bhi qism ka koi Etaraz WAARID nahi kiya hai.
Ibne Taymmiyah also carried out and keep that verdant of Famous Muhaddith Hafiz Badar-ad-deen Ayeni al- Hanafi (rahimahumullah) (856 H) in the Sharha (ie, Kalim al tayib) and again does not change his verdict on issue.
issey SAABIT HoTaa hai ki MOHADDIS HAFIZ AINI rah key NAZDIK bhi ye rivayaT SAHEE hai, aur ye AMAL SHIRK nahee hai.
This also give us evidence and proof that even in sight of Muhaddith Hafidh Aini (rta) also consider this rivaya (narration) Sahih and this act (ie saying Ya Rasool Allah) (Ya Muhammad) is not "SHIRK".
NOTE
HAFIZ BADRUDDIN AINI HANFI rah key iss Book ki Tehqeeq o hashiyaa Nigaree SAUDI WAHABI AALIM Ney ki hai, Uss WAHABI NAJDI Ney DAJL FAREB O JHOOT sey Kaam Letey huey iss SAHI RIVAYAT key markazee RAAVI rah ko "MAJHOOL" SaabiT karney ki naakaam koshish ki hai.
Note: The Tehqiq and Hashiya is been done by Saudi Wahhabi Scholar, and he deceived many by satanic act of showing the Ravi (narrator) of this hadith (ie, Al-haitham bin hansh rahimaullah) to the status of "Majhool". But unfortunately he does not succeded in this attempt because of this detail jirah on the Rawi (narrator).
This is Scan of that Page You can see the colored lines this refute his presentation.
JAWAB-AL: the ANSWER
( by SAUDI WAHABI NAJDI DAJL, FAREB o JHOOOT Ka MOONh van JAWAB)
Haitham bin Hanash Rah
MajhooL NAHEE Hain, BALKI MASHOOR TABAEE Rah Hai, Inki HAZRAT the BIN ABDULLAH 's UMAR Rah SAMA'AT SAABIT Hai
Is Hansh bin directory haitham Not "MAJHOOL" ( , unknown unknown from ) (color : as Fabricator Reputation: Saudi Tries To The show Him), He Is switch instead "Mashoor" (Famous) Taba'i (Successor Of The Companions Of Rasool Allah Alehisalam)
Proof No. 1
IMAM by ABU HATIM RAAZI rah 327 hijri ki Gawahi (Evidence from 327 Hijri's Imam)
book: wound amendment
Author: Abu Mohammed Abdul Rahman bin Mohammed bin Idris bin Mundhir al - Tamimi, Alhandala, Razi Ibn Abi Hatim ( the deceased: 327 e)
320 -
Haitham bin Hanash Nakha'i Kofi narrated Ibn 'Umar narrated it from Abu Ishaq al-Hamdani and Salamah (235 AD 6) Ibn Kuhil. I heard my father say that.
Is the Scan are this
Proof No. 2-
IMAM BUKHARI Rah 256 Hijri GAWAHI ki the
book: History Grand
Author: Mohammed bin Ismail bin Ibrahim bin marauding Bukhari, Abu Abdullah (deceased: 256 e
2757-
Al-Haytham bin Hanash, Al-Nakhi.
Narrated by Abu Ishaq al-Hamdani, and Salama ibn Kahi.
Scan Page
Proof No-3
IBN HIBBAAN rah 354 hijri ki Gawahi (Evidence from Imam ibne Hibban of 354 Hijri)
IMAM IBN HIBBAN rah ney iss raavi ko apni KITAB UL SIQAAT Mey zikr kiya hai
Imam Ibne Hibban (rahimaullah) narrate this Raawi in his famous book Kitab-us-Siqaat (book of the authoritatives (in hadith narration / chain).
book: Thiqaat
Author: Mohammed bin Hibbaan bin Ahmed bin Hibbaan bin forbid bin temple, Tamimi, Abu Hatem , Al-Darami, al-Basti (d. 354 AH)
5967 -
al-Haytham ibn Hobeish al-Naqa'i narrated from Ibn Umar narrated by Abu Ishaq al-Hamdani and Salamah ibn Kahil
Page of Kitabus-Siqat
In HawaLaa JaaT sey SAABIT HOTA hai ki
الهيثم بن حنش rah
Mashoor TABAEE hain aur SIQA O SUDUQ hain, innpar kisi ney bhi koi JIRAH NAQAL NAhi ki hai.
These references are the clear proof and evidence that (Al-Haitham b. Hansh) (rahimaullah) was a famous Ta'ba'i and SIQA-us-SuDuQ (Highest category of those narrators in hadith sciences who are considered Authentic most and neither Liars)
JAWAB N0 2:
Haitham bin Hanash Jaisey SIQA O SudugeQ Raavi key doosrey SIQA Raavio ney bhi iss RIVAYAT mey MUTABE'ATT kar rakhee hai
(Al Haitham bin hansh kind of schools and Siqa Rawi's is also being referred by other Thiqa Rawi ) and they did follow his wordings (muta'be'at)
MUTABE'ATT No-1
Book: Singular Literature
Author: Mohammed bin Ismail bin Ibrahim bin marauding Bukhari, Abu Abdullah (deceased: 256 e)
964.
told us Abu Naim said: Tell us Sufian, from Abu Ishaq, Abd al - Rahman ibn Sa'd said: seduced by a man the son of Omar, man said to him: I remember I love people to you, he said: O Muhammad
MUTABE'ATT No 2:
Book: work today and night behavior of the Prophet with his Lord Almighty and his companions with the slaves
Author: Ahmad bin Mohammed bin Ishaq ibn Ibrahim bin Asbat bin Abdullah bin Ibrahim bin Badih, B «son of the Sunni» (deceased: 364 e)
168 -
Narrated by Muhammad ibn Ibrahim al-Anmati, and Amr ibn al-Junaid ibn 'Issa, they said: Thana Muhammad ibn Khaddash, Thna Abu Bakr bin Ayyash, Thana Abu Ishaq al-Subaie, from Abu Division, said: I was walking with Ibn Omar, may Allah be pleased with them, A man said to him, "Remember, I love people to you." He said: "O Muhammadah, let him walk."
MUTABE'AAT No 3: The
book: Ghareeb al-Hadith
Author: Ibrahim ibn Ishaq al-Harbi Abu Ishaq [198 - 285]
Afan told us a division from Abu Ishaaq. »He said:" Remember, I love people. "He said," O Muhammad! "
In Tamam HAWALAJAAT sey AAFTAAB E NISFUL NIHAAR ki tarah ye baat Waazeh o raushan ho jaateee hai ki
BAAD E WISAAL HOOZOOR sallallaho alaihi wa sallam NIDAA E YAA MOHAMMAD sallallaho alaihi wasallam aur ISTAGASHAA FAIL E SAHABEE radi allaho anhu sey SAHEE SANAD sey SAABIT hai.
These all scans are the proof like shining sun in the sky that saying Ya Rasool Allah or Nidaa (saying) Ya Muhammad after the death of Rasoolullah (sal-Allahu-alehi-wasalam) is valid and that is this act was done by Sahaba (ridwanullahi tala alehim ajmaeen) with Sanad of Sahih Hadith (Authentic Status).
Thus Wahhabi's fabrications and sayings are nothing but scrap. May Allah Guide us all to the right path. Aameen